Africa
4:37 pm
Fri October 5, 2012

Benghazi Attack Raises New Questions About Al-Qaida

Originally published on Fri October 5, 2012 11:07 pm

For the past decade, al-Qaida has been a top-down organization.

Letters seized at Osama bin Laden's compound in Pakistan showed that he was a hands-on manager, approving everything from operations to leadership changes in affiliate groups.

But there's early intelligence that al-Qaida may have had a small role in the attack on the U.S. Consulate in Benghazi, Libya, which killed four Americans, including Ambassador Chris Stevens, on Sept. 11.

If al-Qaida involvement is confirmed, it may signal that al-Qaida has changed.

The broader investigation is still playing out. The FBI finally visited the consulate this week and was already working with Libyan authorities to find those responsible.

Also, two men believed to be connected to the attack were detained at the airport in Istanbul. U.S. officials say they have an interest in interviewing the two men, but wouldn't say whether they were significant actors in the attack.

Based on what's known so far, Bruce Hoffman, a terrorism expert at Georgetown University, thinks the Benghazi attack could signal something significant.

"What we saw in Benghazi was something that was much more atomized, much more disparate and much more opportunistic," he says. "I think it raises potential challenges for how we go about counterterrorism in the next decade of this new al-Qaida."

This new al-Qaida, one without bin Laden, has been battered as an organization. But the group may have found a new role: inspiring local militias.

Intercepted Phone Calls

U.S. intelligence officials intercepted a number of telephone calls between members of a local Libyan group — Ansar al-Sharia — and al-Qaida's affiliate in North Africa.

One call in particular is under scrutiny. It came on the afternoon of Sept. 11, shortly after protesters in Egypt had stormed the American Embassy in Cairo; this was about six hours before the attack on the consulate in Benghazi began.

Officials believe al-Qaida told members of the Libyan militia that they should take a cue from the Cairo protests and launch immediately any attack they had been planning for the future.

"You have now almost multiple layers of al-Qaida," Hoffman says. "You see even the [al-Qaida] affiliates actually interfacing with locals on the ground and taking advantage of their capabilities to deploy them on very short notice."

Africa appears to be ground zero for al-Qaida to test this new tactic.

New Islamist Groups In Africa

Over the past 18 months, Islamists who subscribe to some of al-Qaida's ideas have appeared in Nigeria, Mali, Mauritania, Niger, and now Libya.

"What we see in Libya right now is a set of individuals who've migrated from North Africa to conflict zones like Iraq and Syria are migrating back," says Christopher Swift, a fellow at the University of Virginia School of Law who used to track terrorist financial networks at the Treasury Department.

"Some of those individuals have drunk the Kool-Aid. They believe in the al-Qaida ideology, but they may not share the same short-term political objectives, and they may be operationally distinct," Swift says.

In other words, they often agree with al-Qaida, but they have their own agenda.

And what intelligence officials are sorting out after Benghazi is whether a militia like Ansar al-Sharia — the group suspected in the attack — is effectively a local arm of al-Qaida, or something more distinct.

Swift thinks what happened in Libya could be the future of al-Qaida.

"I think you're also going to see a relocalization process within al-Qaida. What does that mean? It means the future of global jihad is going to be built through local insurgencies," he says.

That it will make it much harder to prevent attacks, because every local extremist group could provide foot soldiers for al-Qaida.

Copyright 2013 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

MELISSA BLOCK, HOST:

This week, the FBI finally visited the consulate in Benghazi, Libya, where Ambassador Chris Stevens and three other Americans were killed. Agents have been working with Libyan authorities to find those responsible. Two men believed to be connected to the attack have been detained at the airport in Istanbul. U.S. officials say they have an interest in interviewing the two but wouldn't say whether they were significant actors in the attack. Intelligence officials are also looking at what role al-Qaida played. As NPR's Dina Temple-Raston reports, the attack in Benghazi may signal a change in al-Qaida's tactics.

DINA TEMPLE-RASTON, BYLINE: For the past decade, al-Qaida has been a very top-down organization. Letters seized at Osama bin Laden's compound in Pakistan showed that he was a very hands-on manager, approving everything from operations to leadership changes in affiliate groups. The Libya attack, if the early intelligence in al-Qaida's small role is true, may signal al-Qaida has changed.

BRUCE HOFFMAN: What we saw in Benghazi was something that was much more atomized, much more disparate, much more opportunistic.

TEMPLE-RASTON: Bruce Hoffman is a terrorism expert at Georgetown University.

HOFFMAN: And I think it raises potential challenges for how we go about counterterrorism in the next decade of this new al-Qaida.

TEMPLE-RASTON: This new al-Qaida, an al-Qaida without bin Laden, has been battered as an organization. But the group may have found a new role: inspiring local militias. U.S. intelligence officials intercepted a number of telephone calls between members of a local Libyan group - Ansar al-Sharia - and al-Qaida's affiliate in North Africa. One call in particular is under scrutiny. It came on the afternoon of September 11, shortly after protesters in Egypt had stormed America's embassy in Cairo; this was about six hours before the attack on the consulate in Benghazi. Officials believe al-Qaida told members of the Libyan militia that they should take a cue from Cairo protests and launch immediately any attack they had been planning for the future. Hoffman says that's the new al-Qaida.

HOFFMAN: You have now almost multiple layers of al-Qaida. You see even the al-Qaida affiliates actually interfacing with locals on the ground and taking advantage of their capabilities to deploy them, you know, on very short notice.

TEMPLE-RASTON: Africa appears to be ground zero for al-Qaida to test this new tactic. Over the past 18 months, Islamists who subscribe to some of al-Qaida's ideas have appeared in Nigeria, Mali, Mauritania, Niger, and now Libya.

CHRISTOPHER SWIFT: What we see in Libya right now is a set of individuals who've migrated from North Africa to conflict zones like Iraq and Syria are migrating back.

TEMPLE-RASTON: Christopher Swift is a fellow at the University of Virginia Law School, and who used to track terrorist financial networks at the Treasury Department.

SWIFT: Some of those individuals have drunk the Kool-Aid. They believe in the al-Qaida ideology, but they may not share the same short-term political objectives, and they may also be operationally distinct.

TEMPLE-RASTON: In other words, they often agree with al-Qaida, but they have their own agenda. And what intelligence officials are sorting out after Benghazi is whether a militia like Ansar al-Sharia - the group suspected in the attack - is effectively a local arm of al-Qaida or something more distinct. Christopher Swift thinks what happened in Libya could be the future of al-Qaida.

SWIFT: I think you're also going to see, you know, a relocalization process within al-Qaida. So, what does that mean? It means the future of global jihad is going to be built through local insurgencies.

TEMPLE-RASTON: That it will make it much harder to prevent attacks, because every local extremist group could provide foot soldiers for al-Qaida. Dina Temple-Raston, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

Related program: